Treasure Island Real Estate Search

Treasure Island Historical Properties for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Treasure Island and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Treasure Island real estate market? Sign up for a  Treasure Island Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Treasure Island Historical Properties for Sale

2 Beds 3 Baths U8222542 MLS
Welcome to Paradise Palms - your charming St. Pete Beach oasis, which is less than a 5 minute walk to one of Trip Advisor's "America's Top-Ranked Beaches! You will feel the sophistication and comfortability of this fully renovated triplex as soon as you enter the door to the open kitchen and living room combination in the two larger units. This property offers three individual apartments with their own private entrances & separated covered & screened patios, and the property would work for multi-generational families or for a rental! While the units have separate entrances, there is an additional option of adjoining one of the one bedroom units with the studio that has double locked door access. All units have been thoughtfully laid out, with plentiful natural light and more storage than anyone would need in a main home, or a vacation home! Updates include but are not limited to: Insurance discount for newer roof with hurricane clips, hurricane impact doors and windows, new kitchen cabinets, new countertops, new appliances, new bathroom vanities, new furniture, new interior doors, new baseboards & casing throughout, freshly painted interior and new flooring. Suite #1: First floor, 1 Private Bedroom w/ Queen bed/1 Bathroom, Full Kitchen, screened in patio at entry. Suite #2: First Floor, 1 Bedroom/1 Bathroom (Queen bed). Full Kitchen, screened in patio at entry. Suite #3: First floor, Studio with full bath and kitchenette. This property also includes a private backyard, completed with a grill, two sheds, seating area and banana trees! Paradise Palms has 5 parking spaces in front. Short walking Distance to several Restaurants & Bars, Shops, Upham Beach, Corey Ave Farmers Market, etc. Property comes fully furnished & equipped. City of St. Pete Beach only allows 30 night minimum rental. It will be the responsibility of any prospective buyer to check with the city regarding current rental regulations.

6595 Gulf Winds Drive, Treasure Island

3 Beds 3.5 Baths U8221783 MLS
~LIFE IS SHORT~BUY THE BEACH HOUSE~ This beachfront sanctuary sits on one of the most quintessentially perfect Old Florida shaded beach lots directly on Sunset Beach on the southern tip of Treasure Island. Hidden under the Australian pines on one of the quietest stretches of sand, you will fall in love with the daily post-card views over turquoise waters. Sunsets here are different hues of beauty every single day and the dolphins & seabirds will entertain you constantly. Perched on a spacious 50 ft beachfront lot, this elevated residence boasts a pristine expanse of new dunes and sea grass, creating a seamless transition from your doorstep to the sugar white sands. The allure of the property is heightened by its thoughtfully designed layout featuring a stunning wood & glass stairway along with three generously sized bedrooms, each complimented by its own ensuite bathroom and a walk-in closet. One of the gems of this coastal haven is the primary suite, a recent addition on the third floor completed in 2018. From the open living- dining room ascend up the architecturally designed glass stairway to find an oversized owners retreat with a large walk-in closet that doubles as a private study. The primary bathroom features a large step-in shower and separate soaking tub or you could sip drinks on your own private balcony. Beyond the interiors, the allure of this special home extends to the outdoors where two expansive decks face the Gulf, inviting you to every sunset. Ample storage including sheds ensures that beach gear finds its place effortlessly, while covered parking for four cars plus additional four spots in the driveway accommodates both residents and guests with ease. What truly set this home apart is its strategic positioning, six houses away from the nearest public parking and access points. Until you live on the beach, you may not appreciate the exquisite VALUE of this location as fewer visitors will set up in front of your home. The roof, plumbing and electrical systems have all been expertly updated ensuring not just comfort but also peace of mind. With clean inspection reports? including 4point and wind mitigations, survey and elevation certificate, this beachfront retreat stands as not just a residence but an investment in a lifestyle. Please see floor plans and videos for more details and don't miss your opportunity to live in Paradise.

8300 W Gulf Boulevard, Treasure Island

2 Beds 2 Baths U8220923 MLS
Beach, Beach, Baby! Welcome home to Pass-a-Grille, the relaxed historic beach town located at the southernmost tip of St. Pete Beach! Pass-a-Grille is the quintessential old Florida beach town with 1.4 miles of powder white sand to enjoy! This is the beach lifestyle you've been dreaming of where everything is only a very short walk away. You can walk to the beach, intracoastal waterway, restaurants, boutiques, rooftop bars, parks, dog parks, pickleball courts, fishing, the famous Merry Pier, Gulf Beaches Historical Museum, and most importantly, Paradise Ice Cream! You will fall in love with this super cute 1935 beach bungalow located on a corner lot with Beach Views! This squeaky clean beach home has 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms with 1240 square feet of air conditioned living space. This single family home is currently configured as 2 separate units, each with 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom and separate entrances. This is the perfect Mother-in-Law property or live in 1 unit and rent the other one out! It would also be easy to make it function as a 2 bedroom 2 bath contiguous home. The charming front unit is a well-kept time capsule of historic Florida beach living with hardwood flooring, wood paneling, custom built-ins and beach views! The back unit has been professionally renovated (2023) with attention to every detail! This unit enjoys an open floorplan with a vaulted ceiling, refinished hardwood flooring, french doors with built-in blinds, custom lighting and fans, and a gorgeous all new kitchen. The kitchen features wood cabinetry with soft close drawers, built-in dining table, wine storage, breakfast bar, high end top quality stainless steel appliances, stone countertops, custom backsplash and more!! You will appreciate the walk-in closet with custom built-ins. There is ample outdoor decking to enjoy the Gulf Breezes! There is room for a pool (confirm with city). Onsite laundry. Major systems have been updated (roof, A/C, plumbing and electric) making this Pass-a-Grille beach home a no-brainer!! This is one of those happy homes you need to see in person to truly appreciate. Beach Please!

113 3rd Avenue, Treasure Island

3 Beds 2.5 Baths U8220445 MLS
Come see this timeless gem nestled in the heart of St. Pete Beach, a classic colonial home with coastal charm. This charming residence is just a leisurely stroll away from the pristine sands of Upham Beach, offering the quintessential Florida lifestyle. The home boasts 3 bedrooms, each spacious and filled with natural light, providing comfortable living spaces for you and your loved ones. Enjoy the convenience of having 2 full bathrooms and a half bath, blending this classic home with modern functionality. This home offers a cozy yet spacious atmosphere, making it perfect for both entertaining or a quiet night in. Escape to your private sanctuary with a backyard already equipped with a hot tub – the perfect spot to unwind and rejuvenate after a day at the beach. The long driveway provides multiple parking spaces to ensure that convenience is key, making it easy for you and your guests to come and go as you please. This home is surrounded by a myriad of restaurants and entertainment, with everything being an easy walk from your front door. Only two blocks away from the popular Corey Ave Shopping District, featuring a variety of shops, boutiques, and entertainment options. Easily immerse yourself in the local atmosphere with a short walk to the Corey Ave Sunday Market, a weekly event showcasing community treasures and flavors. This is more than a home; it's a piece of St. Pete Beach history waiting for new memories to be made. Don't miss the chance to own a slice of paradise in this sought-after beachside community. Experience all that St Pete Beach has to offer! Schedule your private showing today.

543 72nd Avenue, Treasure Island

2 Beds 2 Baths U8219801 MLS
Luxury Home in St Pete Beach: Historic Schoolhouse Turned Modern Residence Embrace History in Modern Comfort: Experience the charm of the Island's first schoolhouse at 105 4th Avenue, now a luxurious single-family residence in St Pete Beach, Florida. Revitalized in 2021, this historic property is a mere 400 feet from the renowned beaches of the Gulf of Mexico and just 200 feet from Boca Ciega Bay's serene waters. The inviting open floor plan, graced with vaulted ceilings, captures the essence of spacious beachside living. Features include a main floor bedroom, two immaculate baths, an upstairs loft, Anderson hurricane-impact windows, energy-saving mini-splits, durable metal roofing, and authentic reclaimed riverbank pine flooring. The modern kitchen, showcasing a farm-house sink and brand-new GE appliances, perfectly complements the home's historical allure. Prioritize comfort and energy efficiency with the state-of-the-art icynene blown insulation. Nestled in the heart of the vibrant Pass-A-Grille community, this St Pete Beach gem is just four blocks from the bustling 8th avenue – a hub for shopping, dining, and entertainment. Delve into local galleries, explore the Gulf Beaches Historical Museum, savor meals at the iconic Don Cesar, or set off for an excursion to Shell Key's rich biodiversity. Commuting is a breeze with the Sun Runner's complimentary service and the picturesque Cross Bay Ferry route to Tampa. If you're on the hunt for a coastal sanctuary, a fleeting escape, or a prosperous investment – this no HOA gem offers an unparalleled blend of historical richness and contemporary luxury. Benefit from a property tax that's only half the standard rate, thanks to its half-lot size. Discover St Pete Beach's heritage in style. Book your exclusive viewing now and discover South Florida’s best-kept real estate secret.

105 4th Avenue, Treasure Island

2 Beds 2 Baths U8219468 MLS
Welcome to paradise! This beach house is located on Sunset Beach and features a ROOFTOP DECK overlooking the Gulf of Mexico. 2 Bedroom, 2 Bath with Bonus Loft and an attached 1 car garage with the option to come partially furnished! On the first floor you will be welcomed by an open living room and kitchen floor plan with vaulted ceilings and a gas fireplace. Also, on the first floor features a bedroom with walk-in closet and bathroom. The second floor features a master bedroom with en-suite bathroom with a large walk-in shower and a dual vanity sink. Sliding glass doors from the master lead you to a balcony with gulf views. Off the master is a wet bar with mini-fridge and cook-top with plenty of cabinet space and a large walk-in closet. Continuing to the third floor you will find a bonus loft that features two twin size beds which is the perfect kid's space or could be used as an office space. On the top floor is also the access to the rooftop deck which is the perfect entertaining space with amazing views of the gulf. Located on a corner lot with parking access on two streets plus private patio in the back. Don't miss this amazing opportunity for a beach house with views of the Gulf of Mexico from every floor of the home and in such a vibrant community. Enjoy easy access to shopping, dining, and endless beach activities. Just a short walk to Caddy's on the Beach, Ka' Tiki, and Sea Dog Brewing.

9222 Harrell Avenue, Treasure Island

1 Beds 1 Baths U8217680 MLS
Calling all boaters! Rare opportunity to own a waterfront property situated on a protected canal within minutes from John's Pass and the Gulf of Mexico. This cozy beach bungalow nestled on a 45'x150' lot has been a family treasure for generations. Located in the Coney Island neighborhood of Treasure Island, you get the best of all worlds; peace and serenity of quintessential old Florida charm, deep water, proximity to the beach, and a short walk to a variety of shops, restaurants, and entertainment. The cottage consists of 1 bedroom, 1 bath, a family/living room open to kitchen with granite countertops, plus bonus room/office/den; a walk-in closet, and exterior shed. The detached 1 car garage can be used as a workshop or for storage of car, golf cart, or boating & beach essentials. Just outside the back door, you can relax and watch dolphins and boats cruise by from the comforts of your private custom built thatched roof Tiki hut. The backyard offers flexibility and space for a pool, outdoor activities such as a game of volleyball, or playing fetch with your 4-legged friends! Fish off the dock or head offshore with quick unobstructed access to the Gulf of Mexico. An 8,000 lb lift and a wet slip provide dockage for multiple vessels. This property is conveniently situated with easy access to downtown St. Petersburg, Clearwater, Tampa, and destinations south of the Skyway. Only 40 minutes to Tampa Intl Airport. You will be hard pressed to find another property with this charm, location, and value. Don't miss this amazing investment opportunity for immediate rental income, or to build your next dream home, or to just enjoy simple island-style life as it once was!

12512 Lagoon Lane, Treasure Island

1 Beds 1 Baths U8209908 MLS
Nestled just two short blocks away from the pristine shores of the Gulf of Mexico and Treasure Island's famous beach, this enchanting coastal cottage is your passport to paradise! Immerse yourself in the tranquil ambiance of beachside living while being only a single block away from a convenient boat ramp, making it a haven for water enthusiasts. Step into your very own cozy beach hideaway, radiating with character at every turn. The exterior boasts an outdoor shower – the perfect way to rinse off after a sun-soaked day of beach adventures. Inside, the cottage beckons with its warmth and charm, promising a restful haven to recharge your spirits. Enjoy visiting the vibrant John's Pass Village and Boardwalk, a hub of activity where shopping, delectable eateries, and delightful watering holes await. Indulge your senses as you explore the eclectic offerings, only a leisurely stroll from your charming abode. With such close proximity to local attractions, who needs a car? Your next adventure is always just around the corner! As the sun begins its descent, prepare to be captivated by the awe-inspiring beauty of Treasure Island's renowned sunsets. Unwind on the beach and marvel at the kaleidoscope of colors painting the sky – a truly magical experience that's only a stone's throw away. Escape the ordinary and embrace the extraordinary – this coastal cottage is more than a dwelling, it's a gateway to a lifestyle filled with sand between your toes, ocean breezes, and memories that will last a lifetime. Don't miss out on this opportunity to claim your slice of paradise – your dream coastal retreat awaits!

135 122nd Avenue E, Treasure Island

2 Beds 2 Baths U8209219 MLS
Welcome to paradise on St. Pete Beach! Come enjoy walks to the beach, the best Sunsets around, amazing dining and so much more. This charming home offers the Ultimate Florida Lifestyle with a Coastal Beach design and the cozy feel of home all in one. As one of America’s Top Best Beaches you’ll be happy you made the move! Step inside to a light, bright and airy split floor plan consisting of 2-bedrooms, 2-bathrooms, an office space and dining area. Your Master Suite is very spacious and enjoys a walk-in closet with custom shelving, French doors to the backyard and a gorgeous, remodeled bathroom with a walk-in shower. The living room has large windows, allowing natural light to flood the space and feel like the outside is coming in. Get ready to be amazed with the over-the-top Chef’s kitchen! No detail was left out and the chef in your family will love it. Featuring custom all wood Kraft Maid cabinetry, beautiful Granite counter tops and top of the line Stainless Steel appliance package- including a 36” Wolf dual fire gas range with grill top and convection oven! The center island is perfect for prep and a great hang out spot to entertain guests. So many updates have been made to this amazing home including Simonton Hurricane Impact windows and doors (95% of windows impact, panels included for the remaining), plantation shutters, hardwood floors, updated electrical with a 220 amp hook up for an RV, outdoor shower, inside laundry (Samsung washer/dryer included), gas hot water heater, UV light in Air Conditioner for clean air quality, fresh paint, circular paver driveway and additional rear driveway with alley access. Step outside and you’ll be amazed by the size of the backyard! This is a great place for family gatherings and fun with friends. There’s also plenty of room to add a pool! The amazing, low maintenance landscaping will have you in awe. Completed with beautiful artificial turf and lush tropical trees! You will love the Belle Vista neighborhood! We have 2 parks, a public fishing dock and beach parking. Take a short walk to the beach, Publix, restaurants, shops and entertainment. St Pete Beach is not only #1 because of our beaches, we’re so close to everything! Only a 15-minute drive to the Vibrant Downtown St. Pete for nightlife and dining and just 30 minutes to Tampa International Airport. Access on and off the beach is super easy and quick, making this the perfect location for you and your family. Here, the Salt Life takes over & everyday worries go away. Current Annual Flood Insurance policy is $4,567. Don’t miss your chance to live at the beach in this outstanding home!

153 42nd Avenue, Treasure Island

5 Beds 5.5 Baths U8184887 MLS
The Ultimate Beachfront Retreat was specifically designed to Relax and Reconnect with a 5 Star experience. So many thoughtful details resonating throughout, you'll love them all! The interior spaces are generous, the outdoor spaces are tremendous and the surrounding area creates a perfect place for Fun with Family and Friends. This one of a kind home, on a double beachfront lot, is next level! The current owners spared no expense and brought in an incredible team of architects, designers and builders to facilitate a whole house renovation and an extensive addition in 2015. This home is not just pretty, it's really smart too...fully integrated technology allows for Elan system access to monitor and control extensive amenities from electronic shades, separate sound zones with 4 inputs in each zone, high tech security etc. For those who have not been to Pass A Grille, it is the southern most point of St Pete Beach. The road narrows as you head south of The Don CeSar Hotel, it takes you back in time as you pass the promenade of palm trees that leads you to this quaint and charming Historic District. The Property is perfectly situated with no homes between you and the white sandy beach. Enjoy the award winning sunsets without even leaving your home, they are truly breathtaking! Just a few blocks to 8th Ave with fabulous shops and foodie enthusiast restaurants. Pass A Grille has a long history of premier fishing; so a fun pastime is just a few blocks to Merry Pier offering daily sunset trips, fishing charters or just grab a pole and fish off the expansive fishing piers along the way. A Yacht Club and High and Dry Marina are also local favorites just a few blocks away. Although most enjoy walking, biking or golf carting around town, there is also so much to do in the Tampa Bay area. Sneak over to Downtown St Petersburg with world renowned museums, trendy restaurants, and award winning sports teams in the area. Tampa Int'l is 30 mins away, making business or personal travel a breeze. Please check out the virtual tour too, you will fall in love with this classic but modern coastal compound; ready for intimate dinner parties or the next family reunion.

1103 Gulf Way, Treasure Island

Start Your Search